Duplicate Bookmark
COMMANDER(S)
Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief
QR Code
G U
- Simic
Created by  Dadavil
Bracket
6.0 - 6.5
Bracket 1
Average CMC Average CMC
Info
Cost Cost
Info
Salt Score Salt Score
Info
Calculating...
ANALYSIS

Overview:

This Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief deck leverages hexproof creatures, mutate synergies, and targeted spell duplication to generate poison counters via Venerated Rotpriest or build overwhelming threats with auras. The strategy combines Aura Voltron elements with a backup poison wincon, supported by clone effects and mutate value engines.

Primer:

Core Strategy:
The deck aims to:

  1. Deploy hexproof creatures (Slippery Bogle, Gladecover Scout) or Ivy herself
  2. Target them with auras/mutate spells to trigger Ivy's copy effect
  3. Convert spell duplication into poison counters via Venerated Rotpriest or massive creatures via Ancestral Mask
  4. Protect key pieces with phasing (Slip Out the Back), counterspells (Swan Song), and hexproof

Key Lines:

  • Rotpriest Wins: Cast 1-mana protection spells (Tamiyo's Safekeeping) targeting any creature - Ivy copies onto herself, triggering Rotpriest twice per cast. 5 spells = 10 poison counters.
  • Mutate Value: Stack mutate creatures (Dreamtail Heron, Gemrazer) on hexproof bases for card draw, removal, and land ramp
  • Aura Overload: Use Strong Back cost reduction to flood the board with auras, amplified by Vesuvan Duplimancy cloning

Mulligan Priorities:

  • Keep hands with 2-3 lands + early creature (Bogle/Scout) + protection spell
  • Prioritize Venerated Rotpriest + hexproof creature openings
  • Reject hands without early creatures or protection

Critical Sequencing:
T1: Land + Slippery Bogle
T2: Land + Venerated Rotpriest
T3: Cast Tamiyo's Safekeeping on Bogle - Ivy copies to herself, Rotpriest triggers x2 (2 poison)
T4: Slip Through Space on Bogle - Draw 2 cards, Rotpriest triggers x2 (4 poison)

Weaknesses:

Critical:

  • No graveyard recursion for auras/mutate stacks
  • Relies on 4x hexproof creatures as primary Rotpriest carriers

Moderate:

  • Weak to board wipes (only 3 counterspells)
  • Limited poison redundancy beyond Rotpriest

Minor:

  • Slow vs flying blockers without Pouncing Shoreshark

Most Important Cards:

  • Venerated Rotpriest
  • Ancestral Mask
  • Season of Growth
  • Isochron Scepter
  • Torpor Orb
  • Twinning Staff
  • Vesuvan Duplimancy
  • Dreamtail Heron
  • Gemrazer
  • Tamiyo's Safekeeping

Attribute Ratings:

Speed: 7/10

  • T5 poison kill possible (Rotpriest + 3 instant casts)
  • T4 Isochron Scepter imprint enables infinite poison with 7 mana

Resilience: 5/10

  • Hexproof bases protect against spot removal
  • Foldsto T3-T4 board wipes pre-counterspell mana

Consistency: 6/10

  • 8x 1-mana protection spells enable Rotpriest triggers
  • Lacks tutors for key pieces beyond draw engines

Interaction: 6/10

  • 7x counterspells (Swan Song, An Offer You Can't Refuse)
  • Pouncing Shoreshark bounce and Gemrazer enchantment removal

Rating Justification:

This deck sits between Optimized (6.0) and Focused Competitive (7.0). It has:

  • cEDH-speed poison kills with perfect hands (T4-T5)
  • Multiple protection layers for key pieces
  • But lacks free interaction (Force of Will, Fierce Guardianship)
  • No infinite mana combos
  • Vulnerable to early stax pieces

Power level: 6.0-6.5

DECK LIST
Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief
Creature: 27
($31.91)
1
Archipelagore
5 U U
1
Artisan of Forms
1 U
1
Auspicious Starrix
4 G
1
Azure Beastbinder
1 U
1
Birds of Paradise
G
1
Clever Impersonator
2 U U
1
Dreamtail Heron
4 U
1
Elvish Mystic
G
1
Gemrazer
3 G
1
Giggling Skitterspike
4
1
Gladecover Scout
G
1
High Fae Trickster
3 U
1
Invisible Stalker
1 U
1
Migratory Greathorn
3 G
1
Nadu, Winged Wisdom
1 G U
1
Parcelbeast
2 G U
1
Phyrexian Metamorph
3 U/P
1
Pouncing Shoreshark
4 U
1
Saiba Cryptomancer
1 U
1
Sawtusk Demolisher
4 G G
1
Sea-Dasher Octopus
1 U U
1
Silhana Ledgewalker
1 G
1
Slippery Bogle
G/U
1
Stormchaser Drake
1 U
1
Trumpeting Gnarr
1 G U
1
Venerated Rotpriest
G
1
Wilson, Refined Grizzly
1 G
Artifact: 5
($22.7)
1
Crystal Shard
3
1
Damping Matrix
3
1
Isochron Scepter
2
1
Torpor Orb
2
1
Twinning Staff
3
Enchantment: 13
($19.85)
1
Amphibian Downpour
2 U
1
Ancestral Mask
2 G
1
Bear Umbra
2 G G
1
Eel Umbra
1 U
1
Lion Umbra
G G
1
Nerd Rage
2 U
1
Season of Growth
1 G
1
Shielding Plax
2 G/U
1
Snake Umbra
2 G
1
Spider Umbra
G
1
Strong Back
2 G
1
Vesuvan Duplimancy
3 U
1
Well Rested
1 G
Instant: 15
($24.27)
1
An Offer You Can't Refuse
U
1
Beast Within
2 G
1
Counterspell
U U
1
Deprive
U U
1
Gaea's Gift
1 G
1
March of Swirling Mist
X U
1
Negate
1 U
1
Repulsive Mutation
X G U
1
Shadow Rift
U
1
Simic Charm
G U
1
Slip Out the Back
U
1
Swan Song
U
1
Tamiyo's Safekeeping
G
1
Tyvar's Stand
X G
1
Wash Away
U
Sorcery: 4
($10.68)
1
Irenicus's Vile Duplication
3 U
1
Quantum Misalignment
4 U
1
Rite of Replication
2 U U
1
Slip Through Space
U
Land: 35
($2.88)
1
Ash Barrens
1
Exotic Orchard
11
Forest
1
Hinterland Harbor
10
Island
1
Littjara Mirrorlake
1
Lonely Sandbar
1
Simic Growth Chamber
1
Temple of Mystery
1
Terramorphic Expanse
1
Thornwood Falls
1
Thriving Grove
1
Thriving Isle
1
Tranquil Thicket
1
Vineglimmer Snarl
1
Yavimaya Coast

Enhance Your Gameplay

With premium accessories trusted by MTG players

DragonShield Sleeves
Dragon Shield Sleeves

Premium protection with industry-leading durability and shuffle feel

Use code deckcheck5 for 5% off
Shop Dragon Shield
Ultimate Guard Deck Box
Ultimate Guard Deck Boxes

Protect your deck with rugged storage solutions

Premium Playmat
TCG Playmats

Elevate your gameplay with premium playmats

Support DeckCheck by using our affiliate links - we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.